By Transition Salt Spring Elections & Candidates, Local News – October 8, 2026 on the Salt Spring Exchange. See the original post here.
All 5 candidates running for Islands Trust Trustee responded to a Community Resiliency questionnaire sent by Transition Salt Spring and the Farmland Trust. See below their responses to Q3 on Smaller Housing Forms. (Overall survey: https://transitionsaltspring.com/election-2026-questions/)
Q3. Smaller Housing Forms: Smaller homes use less energy to build and heat, let people live closer to where they work, and can often be more affordable – all of which cut commuting emissions, protect ecosystems and create more housing options.
Will you support zoning bylaws that allow smaller housing forms such as garden suites, cottages, and tiny homes (aka: accessory dwelling units) as permitted uses for year-round housing in more places? (YES, NO, WITH QUALIFICATIONS)
Eric March: WITH QUALIFICATIONS Gentle density in smaller housing forms is a great way to create attainable housing for our community, I am very much in favour. However it is important not to build an over-reliance on these types of housing. We need to ensure we have housing for all family types and stages of life. Suites, tiny homes, and cottages are vital, but so are modest apartments and, in limited quantity, single-family homes.
Ethan Wilding: YES I would support amendments to Land Use Bylaw 355 that permit more suites, cottages, garden suites, and tiny homes for year-round living where water, wastewater, fire access, and environmental conditions can support them. The rules should be clear enough that people know what is possible before paying for designs and reports. Existing homes should have a practical path to safe, lawful use wherever a safe solution is possible. Smaller homes can help young people stay, let seniors downsize, and make room for caregivers and farm workers. Permission alone does not guarantee affordability, so I would also work with housing providers on lasting affordability and seek clear, proportionate approval requirements that keep avoidable costs down.
Bryan Young: YES Small homes are the lowest-impact housing we can add, and many islanders already live in unpermitted ones. A legal path makes them safer and more secure. As trustee I will propose: -Permitting garden suites, cottages and code-compliant tiny homes or manufactured homes as long-term residential uses in serviced areas, and with proven water supply. Gabriola’s work shows a path for Salt Spring. -Year-round rental housing only through housing agreements with the owner. No short-term rentals. -Simple and lower cost permitting for small homes, with water standards encouraging rainwater catchment. -Lowering maximum house size to 3000 sq ft from 5000 across the island. -Allow one separate service-connected unit to be built on existing developed properties in serviced areas starting with Ganges. It’s simple: more people housed in smaller, water conserving spaces, less forest cleared.
Gary Holman: WITH QUALIFICATIONS. There are already hundreds of properties (including ALR lands) that allow suites and cottages. Only a very small proportion of these property owners have taken advantage of this zoning. I believe incentivizing owners to create affordable ADUs on already zoned properties would be the most effective strategy, and I will advocate for continuation and expansion of incentives such as currently provided by the CRD Rural Housing Program. While smaller housing forms are more energy efficient, most homes on SSI heat with electricity, and the CRD building bylaw now requires electricity as the primary heating source. The location of ADUs is a more important climate factor if automobile dependency and vulnerability to extreme weather events are to be reduced. I will support additional ADUs in Fulford, a service centre and transportation hub, subject to Fulford Water District approval.
Robin Jenkinson: WITH QUALIFICATIONS Salt Spring has explored accessory dwelling initiatives (530 and Bylaw 537). I support cottages, garden suites, tiny homes, home-sharing and co-housing as year-round housing in serviced villages and on already-disturbed footprints where water, wastewater, wildfire safety and ecological capacity allow—not blanket up-zoning of every rural parcel. Moreover, existing dwellings need a fair route to become safe and compliant. Where new permissions add density or land value, housing agreements should secure affordability. Additionally, Salt Spring should pursue inclusion in provincial principal-residence rules for short-term rentals, while respecting legitimate hosted accommodation and lawful tourism uses.