Where Do Islands Trust Candidates Stand on Engagement with First Nations on Land Use?

By Transition Salt Spring  Elections & Candidates, Local News – October 9, 2026 on the Salt Spring Exchange. See the original post here.

All 5 candidates running for Islands Trust Trustee responded to a Community Resiliency questionnaire sent by Transition Salt Spring and the Farmland Trust. See below their responses to Engagement with First Nations on Land Use. (Overall survey: https://transitionsaltspring.com/election-2026-questions/)

Q4. Engagement with First Nations on Land Use: Indigenous knowledge of this land’s fire, water, food and ecological history is vast, and land use decisions made without them risk missing information that matters for adapting to a changing climate, while also repeating a pattern of consultation after decisions are already made.
Will you support a policy requiring early engagement with local First Nations governments before land use decisions affecting their territories move to a vote, even where that adds time to the approval process? (YES, NO, WITH QUALIFICATIONS)

Ethan Wilding: YES First Nations should help shape land-use decisions from the outset, as governments and rights holders. I would bring forward an early-engagement policy in my first year, developed with affected Nations on their own terms. That means agreeing on when and how engagement happens, identifying resources for participation, protecting sensitive cultural information, and showing how the input informs a decision. It applies especially to the community plan, watershed protection, and shoreline policy, where decisions have lasting consequences. I accept that meaningful engagement can take time. We should plan for it at the beginning and explain the timetable to applicants and residents. Sending a referral after the important choices have been made is not meaningful participation.

Bryan Young: YES Early engagement doesn’t slow good decisions down; late consultation does. As trustee I will propose: -A reconciliation section in the OCP, developed with Nations and grounded in reciprocity: what we offer, not only what we ask, including stewardship roles in fire, forests and deer management. -Seeking capacity funding from the Province so Nations can respond and there are sufficient dedicated Trust staff resources. Referrals without resources shift the burden onto stretched Nation staff. -Protocol agreements setting out which decisions each Nation wants a say in, and how, rather than us deciding for them. -Referring relevant development applications and policies affecting First Nations territories to them at the start, with time built into schedules up front. Relationships built early are what make good decisions possible later.

Gary Holman: YES Local governments are already obligated by law to consult meaningfully with First Nations. I will support amendments to Trust Policy and the SSI Official Community Plan, both under review, that will require early consultation and strengthen collaboration with First Nations. The Trust has a dedicated staff position to liaise with First Nations, and I understand that Memoranda of Understanding with a number of First Nations in the Trust area are being developed and concluded. I will support continued efforts to build relationships and partnerships with First Nations on an ongoing basis, not just for specific rezoning proposals, including on issues such as housing, marine protection, and co-management of Crown lands and public protected areas. I support, and will oppose any weakening of Provincial UNDRIp and DRIPA legislation.

Robin Jenkinson: YES Through clam-garden and plant projects with Indigenous Knowledge Keepers, and certificates in co-management (UBC) and Traditional Ecological Knowledge (UNBC), I have learned that engagement requires time, humility, listening and reciprocity. Statutory notice should be a minimum, not the standard for relationships; relevant Indigenous concerns should not disappear when an application changes procedural routes. One example is developing guidance for shoreline proposals, where Indigenous Knowledge about cumulative effects on harvesting, habitat and cultural heritage should shape design alternatives. I would learn from Nation-led initiatives such as Stqeeye’ Learning Society and Tsawout’s development plans, while supporting other Nations’ priorities. Some decisions should take longer to prevent harm and build trust-based government-to-government and community relationships.

Eric March: YES First Nations governments should always be engaged with early and often, and that engagement should be baked into the process. It’s essential to build good relationships with First Nations governments so that we are all operating from a position of trust. It is much faster to have an engagement plan based on trust and mutual respect rather than try to rebuild trust late in the process.